All guides

How to Choose Running Shoes: the Thumb Rule, Step by Step

How to choose running shoes: comfort, the thumb-width fit test, cushioning, drop, road or trail, and after how many kilometres to replace them.

/en/guide/how-to-choose-running-shoes

In 1 minute: save routes, download the GPX and join group rides.

Sign up
How to Choose Running Shoes: the Thumb Rule, Step by Step

In short: how to choose running shoes in 4 moves

How much space should there be in front of your toe in a running shoe? About a thumb's width, and the rest matters less than you think. Choose the shoe that feels most comfortable, not the one with the fanciest technology. There are four moves: decide where and how much you run (road, gravel, trail), try the right size with the thumb trick, pick cushioning and weight for the use (daily training or racing) and log kilometres so you replace them at the right time. A review in the British Journal of Sports Medicine concludes that there is no conclusive evidence that impact and pronation are the main predictors of injury, and proposes the "comfort filter": runners instinctively choose the shoe that keeps them in their natural movement path (Nigg et al., 2015).

This changes how you shop: less obsession with foot type and gait analysis, more attention to fit, the surface you run on and durability. Below you will find the thumb rule, a table by use, what drop and cushioning mean, when to replace shoes and where to save money without giving up comfort.

Start from where and how much you run: table by use

Daily road training: a "daily trainer" with medium cushioning, good stability and a durable outsole. Long runs and recovery days: softer, more generous cushioning, slightly higher weight. Intervals and races: a lighter, more responsive shoe, possibly with a carbon plate (see carbon plate running shoes: pros and cons), used sparingly. Trails and mud: a trail shoe with a lugged outsole, toe protection and a tougher upper. Mixed road and trail: a road shoe with a slightly more aggressive outsole (road-to-trail).

A guide on weight: a training shoe typically weighs between 250 and 300 g in average men's sizes, a racing shoe even under 200 g; the lighter and softer, the less it lasts. Weight matters less than comfort.

The thumb rule: size and fit

Try shoes on in the late afternoon, when your feet are slightly swollen, with the socks you will run in. Between the tip of your longest toe and the shoe there should be about a thumb's width of space (around 1 cm); the heel should stay put and the toes be free to move, with no pressure points or rubbing. You often need half a size or a full size more than your regular shoes. If you have wide feet, look for wide versions or stretchy uppers.

Walk, do a couple of hops and, if possible, a short jog in the shop: if you feel pressure or friction, change model. Lacing can help: a double knot with the "heel lock" (threading the lace through the last eyelet) keeps the heel still without strangling the top of the foot. Comfort is clear straight away: no shoe will "adapt with the miles".

Cushioning, drop and pronation: what you really need

Softer, taller cushioning is more comfortable over long distances and for heavier runners; a lower, firmer shoe gives more responsiveness but loads the foot more. Drop is the height difference between heel and forefoot: the most common runs from 6 to 10 mm; a very low or zero drop needs gradual adaptation, especially for calves and Achilles tendon, because it changes the load. Switching suddenly to a very different shoe is a risk: alternate the two pairs for a few weeks.

On pronation, the research cited urges caution: if you have no recurring pain, a gait analysis is not mandatory and comfort is the most reliable criterion. If you have persistent problems (knee, shin, tendon), see a physiotherapist or a specialist shop; the topic is linked to preventing running injuries.

Advertisement

When to replace them and how to make them last

As an order of magnitude a shoe should be replaced between 500 and 800 km, but it depends on weight, foam type, surface and stride. Signs they are done: "flattened" cushioning or deep creases in the foam, markedly worn outsole, worn upper, new aches in knees, shins or feet. If you can, alternate two pairs: the foam recovers between runs and wear is spread better; a study of 264 recreational runners followed for 22 weeks linked using multiple pairs to a lower injury risk (Malisoux et al., 2015), but these are associations, not proof of cause. Keep track of kilometres: on Velunite you can do it in the gear section.

Do not wash them in the washing machine or dry them on a radiator: they ruin glue and foam. Rinse off mud with lukewarm water, stuff them with newspaper and let them air-dry. Loosen the laces after every run.

How to save money without losing comfort

Last year's models are often much cheaper and nearly identical. A higher price does not guarantee more comfort. Try in a shop even if you then buy online, and buy the same size. To decide how much to run in the new shoes read how many miles a week should I run and, if you are starting from zero, how to start running from scratch. To pick routes with a surface suited to your shoes, see the running routes.

What a shoe really costs: cost per kilometre

A useful way to compare is to divide the price by the kilometres you expect to cover. Example with made-up numbers: a 130-euro shoe that lasts 700 km costs about 0.19 euro per kilometre; a 180-euro one that lasts 500 km, about 0.36. A cheaper but comfortable shoe, used for base kilometres, can cost less than half of a racing shoe. That is why many runners keep one solid pair for training and a lighter one for races and fast sessions.

Before you pay: 6 questions to ask yourself in the shop

1) Do I have about a thumb's width in front of my toe? 2) Does the heel stay put when I run? 3) Are my toes free, with no side pressure? 4) After 5 minutes of trying, do I feel a rubbing spot? 5) Will I run on this surface? 6) Would I like to run an hour in them tomorrow? If you say yes to all, you have found your shoe. If one answer is no, keep looking.

Common mistakes

Buying for looks or discount without trying; choosing too small a size; using generic gym trainers; racing in new, untested shoes; keeping shoes past the end of their life to save money; switching to a shoe with a very different drop without a transition. If you have foot pain or conditions, consult a podiatrist or physiotherapist. This guide is informational and does not replace medical advice.

Send it to the friend about to buy new shoes: in the shop check the thumb rule and the 6 questions together.

FAQ

Do I need a gait analysis?

It is not mandatory: if you have no pain, comfort matters most. If you have recurring problems, consult a physiotherapist or a specialist shop.

Can I run in gym trainers?

It is not recommended: they have less cushioning and stability for the repeated impact of running, and are often heavier and stiffer.

How much does a good running shoe cost?

For training, a good shoe is found at mid prices, often discounted on last year's models: a higher price does not guarantee more comfort.

After how many kilometres should I replace running shoes?

Roughly between 500 and 800 km, sooner if you notice flattened cushioning, a worn outsole or new aches in knees and shins.

What size should I buy?

The one with about a thumb's width (1 cm) of space in front of the longest toe, a secure heel and free toes. Often half a size or a full size up from your regular shoes.

What is drop and which should I choose?

It is the height difference between heel and forefoot. The most common is 6-10 mm; with a lower drop you need gradual adaptation. If you are happy with your current shoes, stay with a similar drop.

Road or trail shoe?

It depends on the surface: road on asphalt, trail on paths and mud, where the lugged sole gives grip and protection. For mixed surfaces there are in-between models.

Advertisement